It’s easy to understand why gardeners might feel confused when they first encounter a cranesbill geranium, Geranium magnificum, after years of growing the familiar bedding geranium Pelargonium × hortorum. For decades, Pelargoniums have been sold simply as “geraniums” in garden centers, window boxes, and patio pots with their bright clusters of red, pink, or white blooms and neat, upright form. When someone used to those tidy, long-blooming plants sees a true hardy geranium like Geranium magnificum, they may be surprised to find a sprawling, leafy perennial with delicate violet-blue flowers that appear for only a few weeks in early summer rather than all season long.
The two plants share a name and a family connection, but they differ dramatically in look, growth habit, and temperament. Geranium magnificum is a hardy, cold-tolerant perennial that forms mounded clumps and spreads gently in garden beds, while Pelargonium × hortorum is a tender, sun-loving tender perennial that is usually grown as an annual in most climates, thriving in containers and blooming continuously in warm weather. To the uninitiated, the cranesbill’s subtle beauty and natural form may seem unfamiliar compared to the bold, showy pelargoniums they associate with the name “geranium.” It is interesting to note that the confusion simply stems from history! Early European botanists grouped both under the same genus before realizing they were distinct, and the misnomer has endured ever since.